Camden exploring and learning from online neighbourhoods
(If you need transcripts for videos in this blog post, please email email@example.com)
Recently, Camden’s webteam has been talking to Will Perrin, Founder of ‘Talk About Local’ about the potential of engaging with citizens in Camden through hyperlocal blogs and local community websites. Just in case you are unfamiliar with ‘Talk About Local’, here is an excerpt from its website describing the project.
Talk About Local is a project to give people in their communities a powerful online voice. We want to help people communicate and campaign more effectively to influence events in the places in which they live, work or play.
As you may know this blog is about developing a new website for Camden that can help us get more people to transact with us online so you may well be asking how ‘Talk About Local’ works in this project. The answer comes from Alasdair Mangham, Head of Information Systems at London Borough of Camden
‘In Camden we are very fortunate to have such a large number of our customers with easy access at home or at work to the internet, but around twenty five percent do not. We don’t want to leave them behind so we are working with Talk About Local to help us build capacity within our communities that will encourage people to go online. Once communities have got their websites up and running we will give them widgets to put on their websites that can give them direct access to the Council services they want rather than expecting them to come to our website and track down the services that are most relevant to them.’
About Will Perrin (an excerpt from Hello Digital)
Founder of Talk About Local – a project to empower hundreds of local communities to express themselves on the internet and former technology policy advisor to Tony Blair.
William has a track record of innovation in public service. He catalysed the last great upheaval in communications regulation by driving through the Communications White Paper in 2000 that abolished seven regulators and created OFCOM. William went on to be technology policy advisor to Tony Blair. William was responsible for the world’s first Government use of YouTube, the world’s first government/third sector mashup, and was one of the team behind the Downing Street e-petitions system the world’s biggest online government engagement system until the Obama administration. William commissioned the Power of Information work in 2007. William is taking a sabbatical from the civil service to run Talk About Local an attempt to scale up his community activism on www.kingscrossenvironment.com to hundreds of communities.
What are hyperlocal websites anyway?
First let’s have a look at the definition of hyperlocal according to Christopher Wink
hyperlocal news (n): information gathering about a geographically-specific community that is part or was once part of a broader coverage area or focus.
Christopher goes on to elaborate the definition as you see below
So here’s what I mean by that. The hyperlocal movement is encapsulating some pretty broad, disparate agendas, from (1) citizen journalists covering their neighborhoods or towns of just a few thousand people or even fewer through to (2) media entrepreneurs who are trying to create news-gathering organizations covering as many as a few hundred thousand people in a specific geographic place — or, you know, data assembled by a computer.
If you’re still a bit hazy on the whole concept, take a look at the examples Christopher gave that helps give you a better idea of what hyperlocal is and what it isn’t.
Some Examples to help make the definition more clear:
- A news site that covers the entire city of Pittsburgh
- A blog recreating a local newspaper’s coverage of a cluster of towns in Arkansas
- A citizen journalism project reporting on the east side of Detroit
- A newspaper beat writer creating a portal for the portion of the county he covers
Hyperlocal websites = Naughty school children?
I think the biggest challenge we face sometimes is what I call the ‘I don’t want to know’ syndrome. Having been a researcher who was impartial to organizational policies, I often found that most councils treated or viewed hyperlocal websites like ‘naughty school children’ that needed to be punished instead of heard or just not taken seriously at all.
Some home truths about hyperlocal websites
There are some home truths that have lead us to where we are today. Given how the social web has evolved recently, its no wonder how its taken some people by surprise and reacting quite negatively towards the significant developments of our online communications and society. A lot of people have called this age “A brave new world” and I couldn’t agree with it more. We do need to be brave to face the changes as a government that wants to move forward and in line with the society it serves.
Citizens now have a bigger voice than they have ever had before and we need to learn to manage the new expectations and also learn that being defensive is probably not the first call to action. There are also some very interesting developments on how hyperlocal website are given more credibility and funding by commercial entities, like what happened to hyperlocal newswire Fwix in NYC. Take a look at some of our handpicked articles on hyperlocal websites that might spark your interest
William Perrin discusses his hyperlocal website (The Guardian Video)
A digital engagement framework adapted for local government (an academic overview on digital engagement and hyperlocal blogs activities and impact on citizen participation by Michele Ide-Smith from Cambridgeshire County Council)
However the reality of it is hyperlocal website can actually help local councils to better understand the community they are serving. Hyperlocal websites can sometimes be the voice of a certain group in a local area that are sharing their life stories and only want to be heard. Most times its about a community of people with common interests or lifestyles who are locally linked together with no specific or politically driven agenda.
And sometimes, since their lives are intertwined closely to their local well-being, its common for these websites to discuss council services and how they feel it could be better from their point of view. And usually when people choose to bring their problems to an open or public platform, its often because they are feeling frustrated and need to vent or seek for help.
Why local conversations are important to local councils
In the video above, Will explains why local conversations are important to local councils. We here at Camden realize that we need to find a way to listen in on those conversations without being authoritative, for example through consultations and other methods of collecting citizens feedback. Not that those methods aren’t reliable, but we feel that each method has a different goal or purpose. The main thing is, we all arrive at the same end product, which is ‘Better services for citizens of Camden’.
Listening to local conversations often outlines a story to a community that builds a picture of how the community is changing or adapting to its surrounding. And changes happen everyday in our communities, therefore the picture changes and people need services to adapt to those changes more quickly and efficiently to allow them to live their everyday lives more comfortably.
Local councils building their own hyperlocal website?
So therefore, you might be thinking… why can’t a local council just build their own local community website so they can control those conversations. The video below, Will Perrin discusses the reasons why this is possibly not a good idea.
People don’t talk to the council, they talk to each other
The reality is people are the same online as they are offline. In the offline world, they talk to their neighbours, friends, family, at their local church or mosque and etc. In the online world, this concept does not change. People will be more open about their lives and the complexities they deal with in their everyday lives with people and in places they are comfortable doing so.
Therefore having a council build a local community website most probably will not work and be difficult to build a community around anyways. The most successful communities online are built organically. And for the community to grow and interact with each other , the conversations need to be real life events based on their day-to-day problems.
List of hyperlocal website in the UK and Ireland
So if I’ve managed to spark enough interest for you towards hyperlocal websites, here’s a list of hyperlocal website kindly collated by Openly Local that lists all the hyperlocal websites currently active in the UK and Ireland. Also if you want to take some of Will’s recommendation of good hyperlocal website in the UK, have a listen in the video below.
Some links to some good examples of hyperlocal website
- Armley Tourist Board
- Bournville Village
- Bridge Ward News
- Formby First
- Harringay Online
- Love Clapham
- North Haven Estate
- Puckeridge Village
- Sheffield Forums
- Shildon Town Crier
- Ventnor Blog
- We love Larkhall
- Whitechapel and Inglewhite
Exploring online neighbourhoods
Early last year, when I was blogging independently at LGEOResearch.com, I came across Hugh Flouch the founder of HarringayOnline, a hyperlocal website for people who live in Harringay, London. He introduced me to the world of local government twitterers that lead me to where I am today. During my chat with Hugh, I asked about his experience running HarringayOnline and came up with some very interesting insights. The paper titled ‘Exploring Online Neighbourhoods’ will feature the background, tips, motivation, achievements and testimonials.
Hope this was useful!